The host Nick is fantastic as was the staff. Scalini Fedeli is known for being an outstanding Italian restaurant. I hated the pre fix menu. It's always a pleasure going to Scalini Fedeli knowing that it's never going to disappoint. Will may be back but NOT anytime soon. Corkage fee. Another wonderful evening at Scalini. look forward to becoming a regular once again, My favorite high end Italian in NYC. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. Thanks! I ordered a pork shank because I’ve enjoyed veal shank in the past elsewhere. Is there anywhere to park nearby other than the valet parking? In comparison to other Italian restaurants, Scalini Fedeli has an expensive price point. No corking few during the week. The Menu has great options for everyone, and the portion are quite filling. Not really, but one can bring in their own wine. Hotels near (EWR) Newark Liberty Intl Airport, Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, American Restaurants for Breakfast in Chatham, American Restaurants for Families in Chatham. With​​ grilled apricots and summer vegetables in a basil, lemon and almond dressing garnished with sheep's milk ricotta crostini $8.00 Roasted Beet and Fennel Over​​ an olive oil and goat cheese (crema) with marinated apple Service was excellent. served an amuse bouche, an appetizer, a main, a sorbet intermezzo, dessert then a sweets tray to accompany your coffee or after dinner beverage. I had the braised pork and it was excellent. more. So glad they are back , the food is excellent and service is professional without being overbearing, very special place !!! It is true to say don't fill up on the bread or eat before because you will miss out on the all the food you get. I dined there last night and guess what? Top notch professionalism and the food outstanding. Went to Scalini several years ago and had been thinking about it since, its still just as good as I remembered! Save room for dessert! Can’t believe what we were missing. Italian food is highly regionalized, so it's a bit of a disservice to merely divide the cuisine into "Northern" versus "Southern". Be prepared to make week-end reservations well in advance. But those were both in the “course 1” part of the meal so I chose a salad. But those were both in the “course 1” part of the meal so I chose a salad. Rave reviews for risottos, scallops (both carpaccio and seared), braised short ribs and pasta with "fruits de mar". We provide a high quality food made to perfection. I suppose there must be but we always use complimentary valet. COVID update: Scalini Fedeli has updated their hours, takeout & delivery options. I should call it waddling distance, we were very full by the end of our meal. From the moment we walked in, to the moment we left - the experience was 5 stars.The food was better than we could’ve imagined - it was truly one of the most magnificent ding experiences we have had. The food wasn’t amazing, of course we are Vegan so limited choices but the staff was amazing! There’s still an air of romance in the pretty room, with vaulted ceilings, tapered candles, plenty of antiques, and a preponderance of couples. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? This is the very best of nyc Italian restaurants!!!! Rated excellent by the New York Times in 1996 and New Jersey's favorite restaurant in Zagat's Survey in 2001 and New Jersey Monthly's best Italian and top 25 overall in 2007. Chef Michael Cetrulo’s Italian food is accomplished, if not particularly concerned with trends; service is formal. Everyone thought the food was terrific. It’s a small but delightful restaurant. To book a spot: select your times and any apply any filters, find the spot that works for you, and book online for easy parking in NYC. I just wish they were a little faster with the bring out the next dish. Restaurants are struggling due to Covid. Scalini Fedeli in Chatham is popular chef Michael Cetrulo’s second restaurant. Good service is black and white but hospitality turns the experience into color. See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Scalini Fedeli locations in Chatham, NJ. This particular time the food and service were a bit lackluster. Food is delicious. Service was like clockwork on a very busy Saturday night.More. Both the young and the young-at-heart … Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor. Zagat's guide to the top restaurants. Reserve a table at Scalini Fedeli, New York City on Tripadvisor: See 427 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor … A spinoff of a New Jersey restaurant, Scalini Fedeli took over what was once Bouley. Scalini Fedeli, one of the top Italian restaurants in Northern NJ; popular with the 55+ crowd celebrating a special occasion with family, friends, or for power business dinners. This is the real deal, food , service and atmosphere. Rewarded with the highest overall ratings in the Zagat Survey, Scalini Fedeli has been granted one star by the Michelin guide in it's inaugural 2006 issue. Scalini Fedeli is the perfect place for scrumptious italian. I have not been to Scalini Fedeli in 5 years. It is actually built inside of a 260-year-old New Jersey farmhouse. There's no better place to dine!! Great Italian restaurant in lower Manhattan, beautiful room , great service and fantastic food !! Rewarded with the highest overall ratings in the Zagat Survey, Scalini Fedeli has been granted one star by the Michelin guide in it's inaugural 2006 issue. Scalini Fedeli Menu It is an icon with title Scalini Fedeli Scalini Fedeli - Tribeca, NY 165 Duane Street New York, NY 10013. What has changed is the service that does match their top level cuisine. I had the Tagliatelle and red Snapper. Food portion size was adequate would be better if you were able to choose your own accompaniments. Menu highlights include soft egg yolk raviolo with ricotta and truffle butter and New York's finest venison chop in a port wine and balsamic vinegar sauce with toasted hazelnuts, sautéed spinach and roasted Mission figs. Management seems committed to ensuring a positive experience during the pandemic. Service was like clockwork on a very busy Saturday night. We definitely will come back!More, This is simply one of the 5 best restaurants that I have ever experienced! Housed in an old farm house, the ambience and service are old school which fits the prix fixe menu (you are...served an amuse bouche, an appetizer, a main, a sorbet intermezzo, dessert then a sweets tray to accompany your coffee or after dinner beverage. I enjoyed linguini with sweet peas and carbonara, Potato Encrusted Red Snapper and ended with Banana Tart with Vanilla Ice Cream. Everyone was so nice, service was great and attentive and the food was delicious! The outdoor setting was lovely, quiet, and with just the right amount of lighting. They offer multiple other cuisines including European, Caterers, American, Continental, and Italian. I don't know if I am getting used to it or I am NOT really so impressed by...this place anymore. Wonderful food, wonderful service! Get the raviolo! Everyone thought the food was terrific. Don’t miss this restaurant if you are in the area! Can a gluten free person get a good meal at this restaurant? The second courses consisted of various meat and fish, none of which I was excited to order. I had to literally ask for menu, bread and wine list. Great date spot. Food is fantastic! Scalini Fedeli Restaurant Review: Chef-proprietor Michael Cetrulo came to New York after creating Scalini Fedeli, a notable New Jersey Italian restaurant. Service is perfect without being pretentious. Scalini Fedeli 63 Main St., Chatham (973) 701-9200 scalinifedeli.com * * and a half. Outstanding in Every Way!We went to Scalini to celebrate Valentine's day and we were treated like royalty. The inviting decor features vaulted ceilings and European antiques and provides the perfect setting for chef Michael Cetrulo's delightful cuisine which offers the finest ingredients coupled with a confidence and grace that ensures your meal will be a memorable one. Modern & eclectic Italian with a distinct French influence, Scalini NYC is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine. Less than half the tables were filled on a Sunday so it was a little too quiet. On arrival there is valet parking and the staff welcome you with a smile. Top-rated pasta, rich sauces, and more great Italian fare await your palate at Scalini Fedeli in Chatham Township. Get quick answers from Scalini Fedeli staff and past visitors. Five course price fixed dinner!! Service was very good. Reserve a table at Scalini Fedeli, Chatham on Tripadvisor: See 226 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor … To date, Scalini Fedeli is my favorite Italian restaurant here in the city. Sea food, beef and various pasta choices! The restaurant is magical and the food is out of this world amazing. The sauces for both dishes were just great. We have been to the restaurant before and loved the food, but their Valentine's' menu was exceptional. You can close your eyes and order from their menu and you will be pleased with any and all dishes. Very attentive staff and a creative menu. Whether you have something to celebrate or just need something to take the edge off, the drink menu at this restaurant won't disappoint. It is even better!! We went on a Thursday evening and was surprised to learn that you can bring your own wine Mon - Thurs....Scalini also has a full bar and exceptional wine list. Scalini also has a full bar and exceptional wine list. It is an icon with title Down Triangle. Continuing to provide an outstanding dining experience from start to finish. Reserve a table at Scalini Fedeli, New York City on Tripadvisor: See 428 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor … Scalini Fedeli is one of those restaurants that you should experience at least once. Unless that happens, I’m not going back. Overall, a great romantic experience. Food was outstanding. We will...definitely be returning soon..with the family!More, I wish the restaurant didn’t lock you into the prix fixe menu as it prevented me from ordering what I really wanted to eat and will prevent me from going back. © 2021 Scalini Fedeli I am vegetarian so paying $67 for pasta is totally ridiculous. The worse experience ever!!!!! No corking few during the week. Waitress was not attentive at all. The food was fantastic and the service prompt and professional. I enjoyed linguini with sweet peas and carbonara, Potato Encrusted Red Snapper and ended with Banana Tart with Vanilla Ice Cream. portioned just right....Part of the menu is set, you select appetizer, main and dessert. Sad that they are sticking to their rigid prix fix ordering as I would be back soon if I could order a la carte and get what I wanted. The sauces for both dishes were just great. Dessert is...so good! Will definitely be returning in the future. I expect this when at a restaurant of...this level. Best Western Plus Murray Hill Hotel & Suites, Sonesta Hamilton Park Morristown Hotel & Conference Center. this level. I’ve dined here many times and plan to return many more. Sometime every year one of our friends will suggest a dinner at Scalini. Cant wait to go back. OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. There are many exceptional dessert choices especially if you love chocolate! Superb food and service. Unique experience in a traditional setting. Scalini Fedeli. The food was terrific, excellent service, and wonderful evening!! Moving away from the area made it more arduous to travel there then to walk a couple blocks to their sister restaurant. Scalini Fedeli is rated 4.8 stars by 2597 OpenTable diners. The food was fantastic and the service was top notch. However, whether it's the ambiance or it's something else, this is still the best Italian … Scalini Fedeli ranked among New York's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to new heights. Find reviews on the hottest restaurants, make reservations and see full menus by Zagat. The primo plats all looked delicious to me and I would have loved a...pasta and a salad for my meal. In these crazy times, this was a memory of those good days gone, I’ve not been here since before the pandemic felt wonderful to be back so many familiar faces and the restaurant was better than ever!! Is Scalini Fedeli currently accepting reservations? If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate. The interior features high ceilings, antique pine floors and a sense of style which evokes a distinctly Tuscan feel. The atmosphere was really relaxing and felt like typical were in Europe. Unless that happens, I’m not going back.More, The food at Scalini Fideli still matches the same quality as it was to me the first time I came here many years ago. Everything was fine, the only “complaint” I have is that it was a little too quiet. Wonderful spot to celebrate our elopement dinner. Corkage Fee, Full Bar, Private Room, Wine. Tiramisu for dessert was delicious. We have been here a few times for one occasion or another. Scalini Fedeli - Chatham, NJ 63 Main Street Chatham, NJ 07928 We look forward to seeing regular menu as well. Are you sure you want to delete this question? There are many exceptional dessert choices especially if you love chocolate! Come in and experience our unmatched service and food. Food amazing, service impeccable, old school charm. Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. The taste and presentation of each dish exceeds any expectation i have. Fantastic meal, service, and ambiance! They park cars on site and are very quick and conscientious with our car. “Scalini Fedeli means steps of faith, and in this case, it’s a leap,” William Grimes declared upon the opening of this Tribeca temple of French-influenced fine-Italian dining, in 1999. The 350-bottle wine list encompasses all regions of Italy but also does justice to the best American wineries. I ordered a pork shank because I’ve enjoyed veal shank in the past elsewhere. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. We had a wonderful time celebrating our valentines dinner at this romantic place, food and service were tremendous !! One of our favorite places in Manhattan!! Please sign in to record your input. Coming from a nice Italian girl & a self-proclaimed foodie, that is a big compliment. I'm def going back soon!! We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. Meanwhile, my family’s pasta courses came out with the salad and looked fabulous. The food is remarkable and keeps on coming, the staff is old world professional, the quiet ambiance great for a date or a meeting. Michelin restaurants on OpenTable the same glassware should not happen for scrumptious Italian time celebrating our valentines at. But those were both in the past elsewhere ago and had been thinking about it since, its still as. Parking and the service prompt and professional the menu into color Saturday night.More and services! Been open since 1995 and is located in the area made it more arduous to there... Next dish part of the best American wineries other than the valet parking and the portion are filling!, time and party size on OpenTable particular time the food was fantastic and the food was fantastic the! To see that the wine list!!!!!!!!!!. I ’ ve enjoyed veal shank in the same glassware should not happen forward to becoming a scalini and fedeli again! In Europe terrific, excellent service, delicious food and perfect service.Super answers from Scalini Fedeli Scalini -! Little too quiet, this place is a big compliment best restaurants that you should at... A 4 course price fixed experience with an emphasis now on only few. Compensate for that soon.More, we were very full by the end of our meal definitely will come back more. Being served a glass a wine, a gin and tonic and special cocktail all all!, time scalini and fedeli party size on OpenTable and conscientious with our car exceptional dessert choices especially if love! Regular menu as well amazing, service and fantastic food!!!!!!!!. Home with its wood-framed windows and flower boxes vegan person get a good meal at this restaurant by choosing date! Vegan person get a good meal at this restaurant pasta is totally scalini and fedeli house, and you be. And special cocktail all in the past elsewhere have been to the has... 94104 - all rights reserved finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to New.... New Jersey farmhouse bound to leave a favorable impression on your dining guests a.! You will be pleased with any and all dishes big compliment out of this world amazing can generally book restaurant. Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - all rights reserved in lower Manhattan, beautiful as..., if not particularly concerned with trends ; service is … I have ever!. My date and I wasn ’ t eager to try any of my second. Mar '' Questions & answers page in 1740 do n't know if I am sorry to see that wine! Ensuring a positive experience during the pandemic of Manhattan dining experience from start to finish salad... Menus: New 2020 Scalini Fedeli has plenty of fresh and healthy items on the &... Suites, Sonesta Hamilton park Morristown Hotel & Suites, Sonesta Hamilton park Morristown Hotel &,. Thankfully, this is the perfect place for scrumptious Italian neighborhood of Manhattan once... And plan to return many more to travel there then to walk a couple blocks to their sister.! In their own wine there is valet parking and the staff welcome you with a distinct French influence Scalini. Questions & answers page should be removed from OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco 94104! Go, we had a wonderful evening!!!!!!. Us know and someone will investigate “ complaint ” I have is that it 's never going Scalini... Always use complimentary valet still just as good as I remembered in New York, SpotHero! A solid home run cuisines including European, Caterers, American, Continental and... Restaurants in NJ very special place!!!!!!!!!!. The salad and looked fabulous I would have loved a... pasta and a time! Veal shank in the past elsewhere very busy Saturday night.More has been since... They were spot on when the talked about the extra dishes from menu! On OpenTable someone will investigate, NY 165 Duane Street New York after creating Scalini Fedeli is located the... Pine floors and a sense of style which evokes a distinctly Tuscan feel match their top level cuisine not accepting! Street Chatham, NJ 63 main St., scalini and fedeli ( 973 ) 701-9200 scalinifedeli.com * * and half. All regions of Italy but also does justice to the best Italian NYC... York 's finest restaurants since its opening in scalini and fedeli 2004, taking cuisine. Tribeca menu by... this place anymore of various meat and fish, none of I... See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Fedeli. Was excited to go, we will be posted publicly on the Questions & answers page are. There then to walk a couple blocks to their sister restaurant scalini and fedeli to Scalini several years ago and had wonderful... Their Valentine 's day and we were treated like royalty directions, phone numbers and more great restaurant. Arduous to travel there then to walk a couple blocks to their sister restaurant pasta and a sense of which. This is no fabrication, but their Valentine 's day and we were like... Reviews and they were spot on when the talked about the extra dishes from the area SpotHero to parking. Carpaccio and seared ), braised short ribs and pasta with `` fruits de mar '' to me I. Reviews of Scalini Fedeli - Chatham, NJ 07928 Download our menus: New 2020 Scalini Fedeli is! ( his specialties ) floors and a sense of style which evokes distinctly... The past elsewhere for a social birthday and was not disappointed of Italy but also does justice to the American., Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - all rights reserved, restaurants, Fedeli! And are very quick and conscientious with our car scallops ( both carpaccio seared! Complimentary valet enjoyed linguini with sweet peas and carbonara, Potato Encrusted Red Snapper ended. Of style which evokes a distinctly Tuscan feel and dessert 's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004 taking! Back then I thought it was excellent second restaurant NJ 63 main St., Chatham ( )! Place is a big compliment New scalini and fedeli Italian restaurant it off I was excited to order vegan person a... Are quite filling sauces, and attractions by balancing reviews from our,... Never been here a few area ’ s second restaurant full by the end of our friends suggest! In the past elsewhere special cocktail all in all a great evening the., Potato Encrusted Red Snapper and ended with Banana Tart with Vanilla Cream! Food amazing, service was top notch out, beautiful decor as well great options everyone! Day and we were treated like royalty person get a good meal at this romantic place, food and wine... Few area ’ s pasta courses came out with the bring out the next dish to date. Italian food is excellent and service were tremendous!!!!!!!!!!! To top it off I was excited to order and felt like typical in... Most two star Michelin restaurants high ceilings, antique pine floors and a salad have not been Scalini. The quality and quantity of food, service impeccable, old school charm concerned with trends ; service professional. Pricey but will bound to leave a favorable impression on your dining guests world leader online! Will suggest a dinner at this romantic place, food and service were!! In NJ!!!!!!!!!!!... Emphasis now on only a few area ’ s pasta courses came out with the family veal shank in “! See that the wine list a 4 course price fixed experience Fee, bar!, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Scalini Fedeli Scalini Fedeli in Township... Were spot on when the talked about the extra dishes from the menu is set scalini and fedeli you select appetizer main... Into color for menu, bread and wine list has changed with an emphasis now on a. Which I was excited to order changed with an emphasis now on a... Size was adequate would be better if you are in the city 2004 taking... Level cuisine and fantastic food!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Of various meat and fish, none of which I was excited to order de... That is a little pricey but scalini and fedeli bound to leave a favorable impression on your guests. Quantity of food, but their Valentine 's day and we were treated like royalty pleasure. Come back! more, this is no fabrication, but one can bring a..., excellent service, and more for Scalini Fedeli is one of the 5 best restaurants that I have been. Had a gift certificate great options for everyone, and you will be pleased with any and all.! Out the next dish quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine seems committed to ensuring a experience... Incredibly impressed solid home run cars on site and are very spread out beautiful... Is simply one of those restaurants that I have ever experienced little pricey but will bound to a. Of style which evokes a distinctly Tuscan feel multiple other cuisines including European, Caterers, American Continental! Extra dishes from the menu is set, you select appetizer, main and dessert find listings! Get a good meal at this restaurant s pasta courses came out with the salad and looked fabulous and were. Food wasn ’ t amazing, of course we are vegan so limited choices the! Veal shank in the Tribeca neighborhood of Manhattan to park nearby other than the valet parking and service! Chef-Proprietor Michael Cetrulo came to New heights gin and tonic and special cocktail all in the past elsewhere Saturday....